DGK - MY BRIEF COMMENTS
The scope of this S.C. Judgement, is not just limited or confined only to Uttar Pradesh Acts alone, but more importantly extends to the underlying concept of the purpose behind enacting such laws, namely, to override the well settled previous judgements of the Apex Court.
( In this case it is Supreme Court's judgement in Prem Singh Vs State of Uttar Pradesh- 2019 ).
It is pertinent here to mention that the legislative intent of 2025 Validation Act/ Law, is to nullify the specific judgement of the Supreme Court dt 4-10-2024- SLP ( Civil ) No 29124 of 2024 [ Union of India & Ors Vs All India S-30 Pensioners &Ors ]. The said intent is explicitly stated in the preamble to part IV of the Finance Act 2025. This Act is a colourable piece of legislation, with a purpose of overriding the settled final Judgements of the Supreme Court, especially its 3 landmark Judgments:-
1 ) D.S.Nakara Vs Union of India (1983 )
2 ) Union of India Vs SPS Vains ( 2008 )
3 ) All Manipur Pensioners Association Vs State of Manipur&Ors ( 2020 ).
Incidentally, we are also heavily relying upon the abovesaid 3 Judgments, in our long pending Civil Appeals, in Supreme Court.
It may be noted here, that the Petitions filed by National Coordination Committee of Pensioners Associations ( NCCPA ) and S-30[ challenging the 2025 Validation Act ]came up for hearing on 03-11-2026 and the matter was adjourned for further hearing on 03-12-2026.
