In private and in hushed tone, people used to criticise Shri RBK for the way he writes. It has taken a serious turn with a few persons taking the matter to open discussion. This time RBK's critics have chosen the Right hand side bar of the blog for their discussion.
The right hand bar chat column has earned some 'notoriety' as it is here people write their free feelings without the Editor's intervention. No editing tool is available for the Editor to edit the comments appearing there/to intervene in the discussion.
You can read the article in question which is supposed to carry "CRITICAL POINTS FOR 10 MARCH 2016 SC BENCH FINALS". Read the article and the comments and come to your own conclusion whether it contains any "CRITICAL POINTS
FOR 10TH MARCH SC BENCH FINALS". This time the Editor has relegated the whole discussion to a back page. Click below.
|9 Feb 16, 11:26 AM |
Parameswaran.nair: I read "SUPPLEMENTARY CRITICAL POINTS FOR 10 MARCH,2016 SC BENCH FINALS" written by eminent writer Shri RB Kishore in RK Sahni's blog. It is cruel to treat the pensioners in this way. He has written critical points for 10MAR SC finals. Pensioners may benefit by his old write ups and the present one. Could you please reproduce his writings and if possible a pensioner may be invited to DEFEND Shri Kishore's writing. After reading all that he has written, I came to the sad conclusion that this gentleman is testing pensioners patience... sorry if I have offended anyone.
9 Feb 16, 12:30 PM
subbu: Parameswaran Nair! Please dont feel sorry even if you feel offended him. He is just a good soul who will never take whatever u say to his heart. You said "he is testing pentioners' patience!! He started testing patience even when he was faculty in MDC in 1980s !! I am a die hard fan for him. His writings are like COs circulars particularly of the type of 31st March closing instructions .. No BM ever reads it if my understanding is correct. In any case, you have to keep up your morale to such high levels as to ensure that your attitude matches your aptitutde for such high prose never attempted after the Shakespearean era. Poor souls as we are, we seldom understand him. But that is our lot. Please dont blame him.
9 Feb 16, 02:39 PM
J.M. Aboobucker: In any article if you want it to be read by the people for whom it was intended there should be brevity and simple and common language instead of trying to show the author's English knowledge and command over the language. Therefore such articles are simply thrown by many in dust bin.
9 Feb 16, 08:50 PM
kn_siddique: AIRIEF blog which is an RBK initiative is visited by a little less than 200 persons. When their conference was going on, I found the visitors number reduced to 150 or so. It only meant that the blog is visited by office bearers of the Fedn. Taking the daily average as 200 (I don't know, number is now further reduced) the yearly visits come to around 75000 which is a poor performance by any standard If Shri RBK continues to write articles like the latest one,the blog will face eventual closure like the AIRIEF blog,Ahd. or lic pensioners chennai. The author's condition while writing the latest NOTE appeared to be critical and pathetic. After reading again and again, I didn't find a single point in the article. I found only English words in their hundreds. It is too late for a pensioner to learn new English words now.. Is it what a pensioner expects from him now? A number of persons write meaningful articles and good as well as very serious discussions are taking place.
9 Feb 16, 10:12 PM
B.R.Mehta: AIRIEF Top Leadership is virtually working with a closed mind. For the last many years AIRIEF Leadership is feeling helpless due to black mailing tactics of one single person whom they erred in projecting as Arjuna of Kurukshetra at their Ahmedabad GC in November,2012. Now AIRIEF can neither discard him nor tolerate his exploitation. God bless all of them.
10 Feb 16, 08:30 AM
A.K.VENKITARAMAN: Shri RBK once wrote abt his eye sight problem in two long paragraphs. This Is the problem. One shd not bring personal problems to pensioners problems.we come to computer with difficulty just to know SC case.. I read RBKs article. What CRITICAL POINTS he wrote. a dozen paras containing nothing. if people criticise,don't criticise them.
10 Feb 16, 11:11 AM subbu: Under the OCTOPUS is written " m v venuguopalan" . Is it an octopus phenomena? !!! From another angle this could be true also, as he has ventured to analyse and take hold of Sec.48 from all angles .
10 Feb 16, 11:48 AM
nithin.b.: Supposing rbk writes on same subject..(sec.48) he may write "MUST ROLL OUT ARGUMENTS & NOT DECLARE ALL AS A STRATEGY. COURTCRAFT BEFORE SC BENCH FACE TO FACE & METHODOLOGY THEREIN TO TACKLE, HOW TO COME OUT OF THE RIDDLE OF RESTRAINT ,WITH DELECTABLE & DELICIOUS ARGUMENTS FORTHWITH, PORTRAYING REALITY OF TREATMENT BY LIC, MOF/UOI ,WITH A PLEASING SMILE… (quoted from article in question). WREST INITIATIVE & WIN ARGUMENTS , CAN BE A GUARDED SECRET ,APART FROM ANY MASTERSTROKE OR MANTRA FOR UNINHIBITED SUCCESS. AT ANY RATE, THE EXCHANGE OF VIEWS, ASSERTIONS, DATA, LOGIC,SEC 48 HOW TO DEAL WITH, WITHOUT ANTAGONISING SC BENCH BUT HOW TO COME OUT OF THE RIDDLE OF RESTRAINT ,WITH DELECTABLE & DELICIOUS ARGUMENTS FORTHWITH, PORTRAYING REALITY OF TREATMENT BY LIC, MOF/UOI ,WITH A PLEASING SMILE..... (some mistakes occured while copypasting) still good for pensioners to know how he writes for US. PAINSTAKING EFFORTS.
10 Feb 16, 12:24 PM
subbu: nithin.b. sir ! Fantastic indeed ! If only were u known to me in 1990s, you could have well entered some ZTC, if not MDC
DEAR ALL LIC PENSIONERS,
SUPPLEMENTARY CRITICAL POINTS FOR 10 MARCH,2016 SC BENCH FINALS
1)AS THE CASE HAS TO COME TO A CLOSE SOONER, OUR AIRIEF AIM
SHOULD BE TO REACH MAXIMUM PENSIONERS THROUGH ANY METHOD OF COMMUNICATION, EMAIL, SMS ,POST ,PHONE,WORD OF MOUTH,HOUSE MAGAZINE VARISTHA VAANI, DEAR USEFUL WEBSITE airiefvision.wordpress.com,THROUGH SRI RKSAHNI'S BALANCED BLOG ETC, SO THAT A MAJORITY BECOME AWARE ,THAT ALL OF US ARE ACTIVE, SINCERE, SERIOUS & WANT TO ACHIEVE OUR FINAL GOAL , THOUGHTS ARE BEING CONSTANTLY DIRECTED TO WORK OUT A PLAN & STRATEGY TO REACH DESTINATION, WITH MASSIVE & PERSUASIVE ARGUMENTS & SUBMISSIONS. SECRECY WILL NOT TAKE US NEARER & DEARER TO OUR AVOWED MEMBERS & MORE SHOULD JOIN AIRIEF. DOORS MUST BE OPEN, WE MUST WELCOME & WELCOME HEARTILY WITH SO MANY ACHIEVEMENTS & VICTORIES TO OUR CREDIT IN OUR LONG, PURPOSEFUL,CREDIBLE JOURNEY OF NEAR 20 YEARS, STUDDED PEARLS OF VARIED BENEFITS IN MYRIAD WAYS , FOR WHICH AIRIEF RIGHTFULLY CAN TAKE CREDIT WITH ALL MODESTY & HUMILITY.
2)BUT WE MUST ROLL OUT ARGUMENTS & NOT DECLARE ALL AS A STRATEGY. COURTCRAFT BEFORE SC BENCH FACE TO FACE & METHODOLOGY THEREIN TO TACKLE ,WREST INITIATIVE & WIN ARGUMENTS , CAN BE A GUARDED SECRET ,APART FROM ANY MASTERSTROKE OR MANTRA FOR UNINHIBITED SUCCESS. AT ANY RATE, THE EXCHANGE OF VIEWS, ASSERTIONS, DATA, LOGIC,SEC 48 HOW TO DEAL WITH, WITHOUT ANTAGONISING SC BENCH BUT HOW TO COME OUT OF THE RIDDLE OF RESTRAINT ,WITH DELECTABLE & DELICIOUS ARGUMENTS FORTHWITH, PORTRAYING REALITY OF TREATMENT BY LIC, MOF/UOI ,WITH A PLEASING SMILE, THAT WHEN ALL IS SAID,EMINENT SC BENCH WILL REALISE WHY & HOW DUE JUSTICE DOES NOT REACH DESERVED LITIGANTS ,EVEN AFTER SUCH A LONG ,GRUELLING DUEL OF MORE THAN 14 YEARS, COVERING ENTIRE FACET & GAMUT OF THE ISSUES & PROBLEMS INVOLVED.
3)THE POTENCY OF OUR SACRED CONSTITUTION, SC ITSELF MUCH MUCH EARLIER IN ANOTHER CASE,ASSURED THAT THEY CAN SEEK,SEARCH & FIND GRIEVANCE HIDING ANYWHERE & PRONOUNCE REMEDY & HERE THE DRACONIAN, DICTATORIAL & MERCILESS ATTITUDE & BEHAVIOUR OF MOF/UOI STICKING TO THEIR BEWILDERING STAND---THE KING CAN DO NO WRONG, THE BUREAUCRATS CAN DO NO WRONG---THEY CAN WITHHOLD, THEY CAN DELAY , THAT TOO FOR YEARS,THEY CAN TURN THE TABLES, THEY CAN SHOW THEIR MIGHT & MAIM, THEY CAN ARROGATE TO THEMSELVES ANY POWERS, UNBRIDLED & UNLIMITED, THAT SUPERCILIOUS ATTITUDE, WITHOUT EVEN CARING TO READ & LISTEN TO INNER CONTENTS OF LIC BOARD RESOLUTION, MANY RTI INFO, I THOROUGHLY ANALYSED & CIRCULATED ,RE CONTENTS OF NOTE PUT UP, COMMENTS ETC,WHICH VOUCHSAFE HEARTILY & EMBRACES THE CONCEPT OF SAME DR TO PENSIONERS AS THAT FOR EMPLOYEES,ALSO REMOVING ADMINISTRATIVE INCONVENIENCE IN THAT PROCESS, & ABOVE ALL , ANALYSING COST & CONFIRMING IN THE NOTE, THAT 'PENSION UPGRADATION' IS NOT COSTLY & SO LIC CAN ACCEPT& APPROVE,
4)Whereas THEY SAID IN THAT NOTE PENSION NEW OPTION COST WILL BE PROHIBITIVE, WHICH NOW, IN WAGE DIALOGUE & NEGOTIATIONS,LIC CHAIRMAN APPEARS TO HAVE GIVEN A MENTAL NOD & TOLD THE UNIONS WHO HAVE ALREADY TAKEN UP THE MATTER .THIS ALSO GOES TO SUPPORT OUR REGULAR PENSION UPGRADATION MORE COMFORTABLY & EASILY TO BREAK ANY DEADLOCK, CUT ICE & SURGE FORWARD TO CLINCH THE TWIN CONCEPTS OF FULL 100% DR TO PRE-8/1997 PENSIONERS AS POST 8/97 PENSIONERS ALREADY ENJOY 100 % DA & INCLUDING PENSION REVISION WITH EVERY WAGE REVISION ,WHICH IS THE THE OVERRIDING OBJECTIVE, VISION & MISSION STATEMENT OF AIRIEF,THE ONLY PENSIONERS FEDN WHICH IS A VOTARY OF PENSION UPGRADATION FROM BEGINNING,WHICH ISSUE RIGHTLY, THOUGHTFULLY & MEANINGFULLY, SRI KMLASTHANA, A WARRIOR STARTED,WHEN OTHERS WERE NOT EVEN KNOWING OR ASSESSING THE PROBLEM OF GRAVE LOSS OF DR & PENSION TO PENSIONERS, COMMENCED THE HISTORIC LEGAL JOURNEY, HOWSOEVER, THE PATH MAY ME MUDDY OR RUGGED, FULL OF THORNS & OBSTACLES, NEVERTHELESS UNMINDFUL OF EXISTING LEGAL, JUDICIAL PROCESSES SO ROUNDABOUT, TARDY, DELAYED, ADJOURNED UMPTEEN TIMES WITH NO RHYME OR REASON , LIC, UOI IN A GRAND BOXING GLOVE WANTING TO ENGAGE SOLICITOR-GENERAL, THOUGH EVEN THAT OPPORTUNITY CAME FROM HEAVENS AS IT WERE, OFFERRED BY SC BENCH WAIVING SUCH COLOSSAL ,UNIMAGINABLE DELAY OF MORE THAN 5 YEARS WANTING TO REAR ITS UGLY HEAD,AS A CIVIL APPEAL CA, AFTER A SERIES OF DISASTROUS DEFEATS & DISMISSALS OF ANY REMEDY THAT WAS AVAILABLE TO THEM--- APPEALS, REVIEWS, SLP, IA, CA,WHAT NOT.
5)PENSIONERS .TESTING TIME, FAST POUNDING PULSE, LUB DUB,LUB. DUB,NOT 72 BUT 92, HEART RATE & DIASTOLIC SHOOTING UP AS RAPID SUMMER APPROACHES, CALM AFTER STORM, ALL PARTIES IN THEIR HEART OF HEARTS REALISING THE GRAVITY OF THE SITUATION , THE SERIOUSNESS OF THE MATTER,AN ATTITUDE OF -LET US NOT ALLOW THE GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY TO SLIP AWAY, THANK THEIR STARS FOR THE SO FAR POSITIVE RESULTS ONLY TO ILLUMINATE THEIR MINDS & HEARTS,LEAVING THE TRAIL OF UGLY DENUNCIATIONS WITH UNWANTED ADJECTIVES & EPITHETS GALORE, & IN THAT PROCESS ,LOSING BALANCE OF MIND, EQUANIMITY, CORE OF THE MATTER, QUINTESSENCE OF THE ISSUES, CENTRALITY OF HARD KERNEL TO COME UP TO BE BEATEN HOLLOW BY SYNERGY & NOT ROCK'N ROLL OR TUG -OF-WAR AMONGST 3 PARTIES, CERTAINLY NOT CONDUCIVE, WE HAVE TO REPENT, WE HAVE TO BEMOAN HOW SO-CALLED 60,70, 80 & PLUS AFFORD TO ENGAGE IN SUCH VITRIOLIC & VITUPERATIVE ,OBSTINATE,OBDURANT REMARKS LIKE ARJUNAS ARROW SHOWERS SO SHARP, MATURE ELDERS, SR & SUPERSR CITIZENS really WANT TO ENJOY SUCH UNHINDERED FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS & LIBERTY THROWING CAUTION TO WINDS,MUDSLINGING GAME TO & FRO WITH DECORATIVE,ABUSIVE CARTOONS,SO LOW WE WANT TO STOOP TO CONQUER ,WAVERING MINDS FALLING INTO THE TRAP LOSING ALL MORALITY,WISDOM GONE WITH THE WIND,ANGER ONE ALPHABET SHORT OF DANGER UNCONTROLLED,
6)PLEASE PLEASE REFRAIN .LET US CONCENTRATE ON THE MAINLAND, WE CANNOT HEREAFTER REMAIN IN THE ISLAND .THE SHORE IS VISIBLE. THE HORIZON IS BRIGHT & SHINING.WE ARE JUST A CLICK AWAY.SURE ALL SO-CALLED POWERFUL POINTS WILL BE LOUDLY SHOWERED & TRUMPETED BY SJIndia & LIC SR COUNSEL.THOSE SHOULD BE BLUNTED & OPPOSED CONVINCINGLY WITH CERTAINTY, ASSSUREDLY, CLEARCUT TERMS & UNASSAILABLE LOGIC, STATUS OF SR CITIZENS & ELDERS IN SOCIETY, BEING THROWN OVERBOARD MUST BE FIGURATIVELY, EMOTIONALLY & RIGHTFULLY BE BROUGHT TO THE NOTICE OF THE EMINENT SC BENCH WITH FORCE & ASSERTIVENESS THAT SC BENCH CANNOT but APPRECIATE THE GENUINENESS & THE OVERRIDING IMPORT OF SUCH CLASS SUBMISSIONS WITH EASE & FELICITY. WHEN WE THOUGHT THAT THE TRIBE OF FAMILY PENSIONERS TO REGULAR PENSIONERS RATIO JUMPING FROM 17 % TO 36 % EARLIER, AS PER LATEST DATA COLLECTED BY ME FROM CHIEF Per,LIC CO,FROM 39.88% , AS AT 31/3/2011,FP HAS GALLOPED TO 42.04 % AS AT 31/3/2015 !! 12,272 FP to 30,731 RP as at 31/3/2011 to 14,485 FP to 34,457 RP as at 31/3/2015 .43,003 TP to 48,942 as at 31/3/2015, A MERE 1125 pa ADDITION to TP as against 1907 in EARLIER YEARS I CALCULATED.
7)What is needed is FAITH,as it is like a life-breath. UNDERSTANDING & BROTHERHOOD will STOP ALL THESIS & ANTITHESIS but, on the other hand LEADS TO SOUND SYNTHESIS,WHICH WILL BE THE SOUL FOR REPLENISHMENT TO MAKE FINAL & EVERLASTING IMPRESSION ON SC BENCH & WIN HANDS DOWN, WITHOUT AN IOTA OF DOUBT, 10thMARCH, 2016
8)As Sri Mahatria observes ,in his inimitable way.hen, how far can the creator be from the creation
CASE MANAGERS,SR COUNSELS HAVE AN ONEROUS RESPONSIBILITY ,LIKE IN T-20 CRICKET TO FINISH OFF WITH A WINNING STROKE, EARNING ALL ROUND THUNDEROUS ,ROARING APPLAUSE FROM THE CROWD & SO TOO HERE, PRAISE & PLAUDITS FROM EACH & EVERY PENSIONER ,49,000 IN ALL WAITING WITH BATED BREATH FOR 10 MARCH, 2016,EARNING & ENHANCING GOODWILL & REPUTATION FOR A TRAPEZE ACT SO WELL ARTICULATED & DONE IN NEAT STYLE TO BRING WELL-DESERVED SMILE,CHEER & JOY TO ALL.
GREETINGS,GOODLUCK & GODSPEED,
(Courtesy: RK Sahni's blog)
We have not made any change in various colours and fonts used in the article BY THE AUTHOR. He sends his article in all these colours and insists it should be published so. We have simply copied without any change at all. We add no comments, but if necessary, we will intervene later. -Ed.